Thirty years ago, Wayne M. Hypes, one of my heroes and a mentor in soil conservation, came into my USDA office in Verona, Virginia, and gave me a wooden candleholder. It was no ordinary candleholder: It was made from American Chestnut, historic wood from a forgotten past. At that time Wayne was a director on the board of the Headwaters Soil and Water Conservation District (HSWCD).
America’s Greatest Tree, the American Chestnut
As he handed me the candleholder, he said, “I made this out of an American Chestnut rail from our family farm in Craig County. I helped my father drag the logs out of our woods with horses. We split the logs into rails to make fences on the farm. I went back to the farm and got some of those old rails and made candleholders out of them. This one is for you.”
When I look back on that moment and feel the candleholder in my hands, I think of Wayne’s generosity, the legacy of a tree that was once America’s greatest, and the tragedy that unfolded in a mere 50 years. The tree that made the wood for my candleholder sprouted most likely before 1800. I was holding more than 200 years of history in my hands.
In 1900, the American Chestnut was the tallest, fastest-growing, and most dominant tree in the Appalachian forest, making up one in every four trees. It was the anchor of every community in its range, providing lumber to build homes and businesses; nuts for humans, livestock, and wildlife to eat; tannins for making leather. Those trees, the tallest in the forest, provided ecosystem services like cleaning air and water and providing wildlife habitat.
An Invasive Foreign Fungus Attacks American Chestnut Trees
In 1904, in the New York Zoological Park, a lethal fungus from China was discovered that would infect every single Chestnut tree, and by 1954 the trunks, branches, and stems of almost every tree were all dead (the fungus doesn’t kill the root). The infection and the subsequent death of the trees were referred to as the chestnut blight. It is often considered the greatest natural resource disaster in American history.
Wayne was born in 1920. By that time the fungus was spreading from its source in New York to many parts of the range. My mentor grew up on a farm in the Sinking Creek Valley of Craig County, Virginia, in the heart of the range of American Chestnut. He must have been fond of the giant trees on his farm, most of them towering over 100 feet tall, and I’m sure he enjoyed the sweet flavor of its bountiful nuts.
When he started college at Virginia Tech in 1938, he must have noticed the march of death of his beloved trees. The Japanese attacked Pearl Harbor on December 7, 1941. Wayne had recently graduated from Virginia Polytechnic Institute (now Virginia Tech) but was too young to receive his commission in the United States Army. Instead, he joined the Civilian Conservation Corps and worked with the corps until he was old enough to fight in the war. When he turned 18, he got his commission as a second lieutenant and immediately went to fight the Japanese in the South Pacific. It must have broken his heart when he returned to find the mountains brown with dead trees and all the towering giants on his farm dead.
Wayne M. Hypes, soil conservationist, soldier, American Chestnut lover, died in 2005.
In Search of Resistance
There has been an epic and heroic quest to bring back the American Chestnut ever since the dreaded fungus was discovered. Devoted tree lovers seek out the elusive trees that have survived the blight. Scientists can use their nuts to continue selecting for disease resistance. A few trees are still standing such as the one in Amherst County, Virginia. Susan Freinkel, the author of American Chestnut: The Life, Death, and Rebirth of a Perfect Tree, describes the tree as “an aging champion struggling to stay upright until the last round.”
The Thompson Tree—Born from Nuclear Irradiation
There’s one tree that has achieved the most disease control in America, according to plant pathologist Dr. Gary Griffin of Virginia Tech. Called the Thompson Tree, it resides in the Lesesne State Forest in Nelson County, Virginia.
It stands alone with a rickety fence around it on the eastern slope of Three Ridges Mountain. In the 1950s during an initiative that then-president Eisenhower called “atoms for peace,” Albert Dietz irradiated thousands of chestnut seeds with Cobalt 60. Many of those seeds were planted at Lesesne State Forest. Few survived, but on one of the surviving roots Dr. Griffin and Tom Dierauf, chief of forest research with the Virginia Department of Forestry, grafted two sprigs from a resistant native in Appomattox County, Virginia. Those two sprigs are the largest tree trunks in the background of the picture below.
Rebirth of the Perfect Tree
How do we beat the blight and restore the tree? The American Chestnut Foundation names three main strategies: breeding, biotechnology, and biocontrol. The most promising effort so far has been to breed resistance into the tree. The Chinese Chestnut is resistant to the fungus. Scientists with the American Chestnut Foundation use a method called back-cross breeding by which they cross-pollinate a true American Chestnut with a true Chinese Chestnut, which results in a hybrid that is half American and half Chinese. They then back cross this hybrid with true American Chestnuts, selecting for resistance until they achieve a Chestnut that is 15/16 American and 1/16 Chinese. This work takes decades of patience and dedication.
Restoration American Chestnut 1.0
The result of the back-cross breeding process is called a Restoration American Chestnut 1.0. By joining the American Chestnut Foundation, you can support its research and acquire Restoration American Chestnut seeds to plant. In 2016 I planted several of the nuts.
I received four nuts this year and will plant them on our farm at Whiskey Creek Angus in Churchville, Virginia.
In addition to Freinkel’s book linked above, another great read about the tree, with lots of pictures and stories, is Mighty Giants, An American Chestnut Anthology, by Chris Bolgiano.
Reverence for Wood
I cherish the wooden candleholder Wayne made for me. It’s in a prominent place in our home, and every time I look at it, I think of the good times we had together, the legacy of America’s greatest tree, and the dedication of all the people restoring it to the forest.
Bobby: Thanks for sharing this interesting history of the American chestnut. Growing up in Connecticut in the 1950s I remember lots of chestnut trees, but haven’t seen one in the greater Washington area in years. Great to hear they are making a comeback!
Ridge, thanks for stopping in with your kind words. Good to hear from you.
Great story, Bobby! Thanks.
You are welcome, John. We had some of your great wine last night.
Excellent article. I have been working with Bryan Koontz in the past. Bryan was associated with University of Syracuse. Would love to know where to get a few seedlings.
Thanks, David. Good to hear from you. Not sure about seedlings but you can get nuts from ACF.
Would love to see an updated picture of your son, grandson and the tree from 2017. Five years is a long time in the life of a tree and a toddler 🙂
Ann, thanks. Yes, there sure is. That tree and the grandson are doing well and have grown a lot. The Japanese Beetles totally destroy the leaves but it comes back. I saw your communication with John. He has a great presentation.
Great post. I think you know that I’ve planted 15 or 20 of those wonderful trees on my farm in Clarke Co VA.
I was not very good about keeping track of the identifying tags with the individual planted trees, ( extremely unscientific, I know!)
Some of them are 15/16 backcrosses and some are different, maybe even a few genetically modified ones. I’m not sure.
What is interesting is that I have a grove of 10 or so planted on a gentle hillside with full sun, and the difference between them us astounding. Even though they are only approx 20 ft apart, and have been in place for 10 years now they are all totally different in size. All planted at same time. 2 are about the size of a small dogwood, 4 are about the size of a 4 ft shrub and one comes back every year with one leaflet and it has never grown an inch. It is still approx 8 inches tall, but it does leaf out every year.
Tenacious little SOB!
Gotta love that will to live…
I don’t think that one is going to make 100 ft tall like the one’s in the picture you sent this morning but one never knows…
BTW… the candleholder is way cool, and the American Chestnut FDN in Ashville NC is doing a great job in trying to repopulate the Appalachains with American Chestnut trees..
As always, all the best, George
Thanks, George! Quite a story of your chestnuts. The first year I planted the high-priced nuts, the chipmunks ate every single one.
Great, inspiring post Bobby. Thank you for sharing it with us.
Thanks for taking the time to read and comment, Robin.
Ah, Bobby, you’ve done it again! How can I get done with what I need to do when your stories keep calling for response! Yes, and your photos tell the most critical part of the American Chestnut story…that of the generations of attentive care and experimentation required to get this far, to the Restoration chestnut. If I still had ground to plant on, I would surely be writing for nuts! I’m glad you have done that, for several like me. Bravo! Anne
Anne, thanks as always for your comments. I hope you are doing well.
Bobby, thanks so much for lifting up the American chestnut, the Foundation, and for setting the example of planting chestnuts. One of my priorities for the farm is to plant chestnuts and your blog serves to remind me of how important that could be. Hope you, Jeanne and your family are enjoying spring! Joy
Joy, good to hear from you. Thanks for stopping in and good luck with planting your trees.
I great story Bobby. That is the beauty of wood. You can’t work a piece of wood, discovering the grain and imperfections as you go, without it being a personal experience. That is why I love trees and working with wood. Watching a tree you have planted grow is like watching your children grow but on a wholly different time scale! Thanks for the inspiring piece. I’m going to try to get some seeds!
Thanks so much, Al. You are so right!
Fine stuff here, Bobby, and while Quercus alba will always be my personal fave tree, the loss of the American chestnut was a cataclysmal blow to ecosystems across the eastern US. I still remember (barely) my grandfather describing how, as the blight accelerated across southern Kentucky in the 30s, entire hillsides “looked like they’d been burnt.” The ongoing back-cross breeding remedy promises to one day restore this mighty giant to the landscapes with which it coevolved. Thanks much for this! –Bill–
Thanks for the story, Bill. Hope you are well.
Love the pictures..
What a sad, but inspiring post-hope springs eternal with the work of so many. Love George O’s reply and story of his “tenacious little SOB!” Gorgeous photos…. The old grove, you, your son and grandson, and young Bobby Whitescarver. I shall order some seeds and mark them scientifically😉
Thank you for this gift of knowledge, Bobby.
What a sweet note! Thank you so much, Sarah.
Great read and information, keep up the great work. I remember the chestnut tree in our yard in Roanoke and the English Walnut tree also. We need more tree nuts, like you.
I just learned something new! Thank you Bobby!!
Thank you, Heidi, for taking the time to read this.
How can I buy a few seed nuts?
Join The American Chestnut Foundation at the seed level of membership.
Bobby, we just visited the Flight 93 Museum near Shanksville, PA, and if I heard the Interior Department volunteer correctly, they have planted app 80,000 American Chestnut trees! They are now about 94% American Chestnut. 730 were added on Earth Day 2022.
Great progress if most live!
Way cool, Sarah. Thanks for sharing this.
The science behind the genetic back-crossing to achieve a plant that is nearly pure American Chestnut with resistance to the fungus is so fascinating! The work put in the preserve the species and the history is very admirable. Thank you for this article!
You are welcome, Karlee. Yes, indeed, there is so much dedication.